Showing posts with label Access to Knowledge. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Access to Knowledge. Show all posts

Friday, August 28, 2009

Access to Research - The Seeds of Thought, the Wisdom of Tradition


Access to patented seed for research and development has been very much in the news of late. Of course, it is not the patent necessarily rendering a product inaccessible for research, but the agreements licensing the seed.

27 representatives of the research community and industry met in Ames, Iowa, 30 June 2009, to consider the issues surrounding access to research in the seed industry. The meeting generated discussion on a set of principles to support public sector research on commercial, patented seed products. The final version of these principles will be presented to the major industry bodies for approval in September (going to the Biotechnology Industry Organization (BIO) 10 September, and to the American Seed Trade Association (ASTA) Executive Committee of the Board of Directors, 17 September). Their implementation by the industry will be of interest.
Although agricultural biotechnology is a significant commercial and innovative bonus to the seed industry, its promise for food security in the developing world is less certain and more socio-political. Wilhelmina Quaye argues that agricultural biotechnology is a socio-cultural issue. Writing in Business Daily, Quaye says in order to improve the use of biotechnology for food security and advancement in developing countries, the communities themselves must be involved in its implementation and development: "it must improve their capacity rather than create ties of dependency." Quaye also notes in Africa in particular the fear over losing traditional ways of farming: "The bottom line is that anyone developing biotechnologies must respond effectively to the intended users' needs and aspirations ... To do this, biotech agendas must consider the socio-cultural realities in Africa."

In the United States, the real significance of traditional agricultural knowledge and practices is starting to be recognised. The US Department of Agriculture (USDA) recently released the 2007 Agricultural Census, which is the first to count all individual Native American farmers on reservations across the country. Native Americans in Arizona, for instance, have been found to operate more than half that State's farms and ranches. And the numbers are expected to be even higher. Despite efforts to publicise the Census widely, including meeting with tribal leaders to discuss the process, individuals were inevitably missed. Farms are generally smaller than the national average, but nearly the entirety of the Dine reservation is under cultivation or grazing. One Hopi farmer, Richard Kuwunvana (pictured at right), says, "Our family has farmed this land forever. We're part of the corn, and it's part of us."

Tuesday, August 18, 2009

Seeded Players - Corporate Control in Agricultural Research

Genetic modification is not infrequently referred to as the future for food security and agricultural sustainability in developing countries. This alone is perhaps a controversial statement and many would take issue - for instance, questions of environmental security and loss of agricultural biodiversity are just some of the major questions raised.

But rather crucially, apart from debates over the nature of the technology, there must be access to that technology, not only for its immediate application but also for its ongoing development and improvement. This is a major issue raised in a recent editorial in Scientific American. Agritech companies like Monsanto and Syngenta are regularly requiring those purchasing their seed to contract out of any research or experimental use exemption that might be provided in patent law and other areas of intellectual property law. Such an exemption (often referred to as the experimental-use defence) allows for research on a patented invention in order to continue to the cycle of innovation. In other words, research conducted upon a patented invention is exempted from infringement. Indeed, this is perhaps one of the fundamental and historical premises of patent law - that is, to disclose an invention in order to acquire a monopoly. It may be argued by some that this is a legitimate exploitation of the monopoly, however such contractual restrictions may persist well beyond the life of a patent, thus compromising the supposed calculation of time needed to balance the costs of research and development and the public benefit of access to innovation. Thus, if such an agreement can override exceptions for research and become a genuine and explicit obstacle to independent research, then the notion of "user rights" sometimes applied to exceptions in patent law and other areas of intellectual property becomes somewhat problematic, if not specious. But what of the rights of purchasers of seed?
Thus, it is not an issue with patent law per se, but an issue of contract law. If the exception is not to be compromised, the relevant legislation must preclude a contractual condition having effect. But this is an issue that is not necessarily addressed in the applicable legislation, not only in the US but also in the UK and elsewhere in Europe. Similarly, many developing countries have introduced patent regimes that neglect this protection. Nevertheless, in Europe the rights of the user with respect to research conducted upon seeds may indeed be less ambiguous. For instance, in relation to plant variety rights, Switzerland has implemented recently a separate defence to prevent the practice of contracting out of the research exception (Article 8), restricted of course to plant variety aspects. Many have recommended that this sort of protection should be harmonised throughout Europe (and indeed internationally).
According to Scientific American, the agreements deployed by Monsanto and others "have explicitly forbidden the use of the seeds for any independent research. Under the threat of litigation, scientists cannot test a seed to explore the different conditions under which it thrives or fails ... And perhaps most important, they cannot examine whether the genetically modified crops lead to unintended environmental side effects." As the article explains, research is still published, but only that research approved by the company itself, completely disabling the intellectual freedom of scientific research and perhaps also the objectivity upon which scientific knowledge bases its import.

Monday, August 17, 2009

Access to Knowledge for Patent Offices


Under the Access to Research for Development and Innovation (aRDi) scheme, Patent offices in developing countries will be given greater access to 150 online scientific journals by the end of the year. The scheme was launched in July by the World Intellectual Property Organisation (WIPO) in partnership with major scientific publishers, including Elsevier, Oxford University Press, Springer Science+Business Media, and Taylor & Francis, and linked to one of the key recommendations of the WIPO Development Agenda. Recommendation 8 of Cluster A (Technical Assistance and Capacity Building) of the 45 Adopted Recommendations under the WIPO Development Agenda, calls for WIPO "to develop agreements with research institutions and with private enterprises with a view to facilitating the national offices of developing countries, especially LDCs, as well as their regional and sub-regional intellectual property organizations to access specialized databases for the purposes of patent searches." According to the Science and Development Network, the scheme will facilitate the process of patent examination in developing countries, with 50 least-developed countries being provided with free subscriptions and 57 developing countries offered low-cost subscriptions.

Saturday, January 24, 2009

Wikipedia for Agriculture

Scientists in India have launched Agropedia, an "agricultural Wikipedia."

The project was first devised around 3 years ago by project lead, T V Prabhakar. Prabhakar, of the Indian Institute of Technology in Kanpur, saw a need for the equivalent of Wikipedia to be created for global agriculture. The project was revised to focus on information specific to India.

The 85 million rupee project will be implemented over 30 months to provide on-line access to agricultural information and knowledge throughout the country. Funded by the Indian government (the National Agriculture Innovation Project (NAIP)) and World Bank, resources will include information on crops and practices, regional knowledge and relevant research. Its primary objective is to provide an effective dissemination mechanism not only for researchers and students, but also farmers and agricultural extension workers.

The website launched with information on 9 crops - rice, wheat, sugarcane, lychee, groundnut, sorghum, chickpea, vegetable pea and pigeon pea - but the objective is to expand the resource so as to include all information related to agriculture and agricultural practice.

In true wiki-style, Agropedia is a dynamic resource to which content is constantly added and reviewed. Agricultural researchers are invited to validate information through the "open source" wiki model, but additional review will no doubt emerge through user feedback and contributions. Blogs and user forum facilities enhance and broaden the kind of knowledge provided and exchanged through the project.



The 7 consortium partners in the project include the International Crop Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics (ICRISAT); Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur (IITK); Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay (IITB); G B Pant University of Agriculture and Technology (GBPUAT); Indian Institute of Information Technology and Management, Kerala (IIITM-K); National Academy of Agricultural Research Management (NAARM); and the University of Agricultural Sciences, Dharwad (UASD).

The first stage of the project involved refining the mechanism to manage the knowledge, with the next phase to concentrate on dissemination, with trials to commence in 6 locations around the country.

Dissemination is not a straightforward exercise. While access to the necessary communication technology may be difficult for some, the resource will nevertheless improve the infrastructure to deliver information to all farmers. With the cooperation of agricultural extension workers and the establishment of around 12000 information technology-enabled rural information centres, the introduction of Agropedia should improve the accessibility of agricultural information whether directly or through farming networks. Innovative approaches to innovation are therefore very important. For example, V Balaji, head of knowledgment management and sharing at ICRISAT, has suggested that Agropedia resources might be used in various ways to disseminate information, including radio plays.
As one of the agricultural centres of the world and in a region rich with traditional agricultural practices and knowledge, India possesses unique resources for its ongoing development. This kind of enterprise has the potential to provide a significant facility for detailing and sustaining that development.

Wednesday, August 20, 2008

European Commission Open Access Pilot

The European Commission launched today a pilot project in open access research.

Pointing the the importance of access to research results as a driver of the knowledge-based economy, the Commission announced that it would use the pilot to disseminate EU 7th Research Framework Programme (FP7) project results as widely as possible. FP7 will fund more than 50 billion euros over 2007-2013 and the pilot will include results from projects in health, environment, social sciences, energy and information and communication technologies. Other EU projects relevant to the initiative include OAPEN (Open Access Publishing in European Networks) and e-SciDR (e-science digital repositories).
The project is part of the response of EU research ministers to examine the application of open access in FP7, as described in the February 2007 Communication on "Scientific information in the digital age: access, dissemination and preservation". It is complemented by the eContentplus programme, announced in 2005, which is committed to providing multi-lingual access to content.

The project is to give access to the EU-funded research results by placing them online for unrestricted access after an initial period of 6-12 months, making such results progressively much more widely available. The embargo period of 6-12 months is described as a limited period during which time publishers can get a return on their investment - a kind of management of the commons in the traditional sense.

The EU Commissioner for Science and Research, Janez Potocnik (pictured at left), said "This open access pilot is an important step towards achieving the 'fifth freedom', the free movement of knowledge amongst Member States, researchers, industry and the public at large."

Monday, August 04, 2008

Global Science - Threat to Local Innovation?


With all the row on press freedom and Internet access in China during the Olympics, it is interesting to note other obstacles to knowledge, including those threatening the dissemination of local knowledge and development.

In a recent article in Nature, 24 July, Lan Xue, Director of the China Institute for Science and Technology Policy, Tsinghua University, Beijing, raises issues with the globalisation and corporatisation of science and the possible threat to local innovation in China and other developing countries.

With participation and collaboration in global innovation, China's role in innovation is a marked development on its traditional manufacturing position in the market. However, participating as an innovator in the trade in global knowledge may actually limit China's ability to build capacity and development in various technical industries. Disseminating and repeating the knowledge is perhaps more critical to China's development than patent applications. Further, perceived obstructions to the flow of knowledge through intellectual property protection (whether through working that knowledge or accessing scientific publications) may also dictate research priorities other than those of immediate importance to China or other developing countries: "Research priorities in developing countries may be very different from those in developed nations, but as sicence becomes more globalized, so too do priorities. At the national level, developing countries' research prioirites increasingly resemble those of the developed nations."

Having access to knowledge for ongoing research and development, as distinct from realising the products of that knowledge in global trade, is of particular concern to researchers in China. As Lan Xue explains, "for a country in development, the application of knowledge in productive activities and the related social transformations are probably more important than the production of the knowledge itself."

Wednesday, October 11, 2006

European Study on Scientific Publication


The European Commission has published a synthesis report on a public consultation on the scientific publication system in Europe.

In January this year, the comprehensive "Study on the economic and technical evolution of the scientific publication markets in Europe" was published. Commissioned by DG-Research, the 108 page study was undertaken in the economic and policy context of debates concerning access to scientific research and results, the archiving of materials, and relevance of the publication market not only to dissemination but also to the certification of "quality."

A public consultation on the study was launched and undertaken 31 March to 15 June 2006, drawing substantial input from various stakeholders, which have now been distilled in a report on the public consultation.

A recommendation in the original report receiving substantial support in the consultation was to guarantee public access to publicly-funded research results shortly after publication. This is important in that it balances the "commercial" value of the research publication and the need to dissemination quality research as quickly and widely as possible. The use of "open access archives" for EC-funded research received support in a wide range of submissions, including the response from the Wellcome Trust. The Wellcome Trust is the lead partner in the UK PubMed Central Implementation Group (UKPMC), which is working towards establishing a UK version of PubMed Central (PMCI) system of networked digital archives. The Wellcome Trust has a noted commitment to effective open access publishing in biomedical research.

Nevertheless, some responses expressed concern over trends towards open access publishing, mostly those from publishers. In particular, the response from Wiley is strikingly similar in its concerns (and wording) as the response from the Association of American Publishers (AAP), both of which state that there is "no credible evidence" that open access publishing is more effective. AAP describes the system as an "author-pays" system. Both responses make exactlyh the same statement - that "no credible evidence is presented that such models are inherently better than the current ones employed or that they have the necessary long-term viability." At least the industry line is readily available.

The Commission will host a conference on scientific publication issues in Brussels next year, 15-16 February.

Sunday, October 08, 2006

Access to Research - FAO Agora


The United Nations (UN) Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) has launched the second phase of its Global Online Research in Agriculture (AGORA) initiative.

AGORA was introduced in 2003, contributing the UN Millenium Development Goals. A public-private partnership between the FAO and 37 international science publishers, together with the World Health Organization (WHO), Cornell University, and other key partners, the aim of AGORA is to provide access to 69 low-income countries. The second phase expands that access to include universities and other higher education institutions, as well as government ministries and non-governmental organizations in an additional 37 middle income countries.

Eligible institutions are invited to subscribe, which involves registering for a free 3 month trial and then paying an annual subscription of US$1000. All subscription income is then re-invested into local training initiatives.

In its press release, the FAO describes AGORA as "closing the knowledge gap." AGORA is a notable manifest response to the importance of information in economic development.

Tuesday, May 30, 2006

PLoS Clinical Trials Launched - An Efficient Consortium


The Public Library of Science (PLoS) has just launched PLoS Clinical Trials, a new open access scientific publication for reports of randomised trials in all areas of medicine and public health.

In providing international peer-reviewed open-access publication of clinical trials, it is suggested that the journal will achieve greater diversity and transparency in the reporting of such trials. This process of publication is driven by the esteem of scientific research, rather than the needs of commercialisation of that research. In other words, it may seem to run contrary to the obstacles perceived to be indirectly put in place by the patent system, where the value of research is driven not by its exchange but by its secrecy.

Speaking in 2001 on the politics behind the race to map the human genome, Sir John Sulston described in interview in Nature Medicine, the way in which the rush to exploit each item of knowledge along the way inhibits the cooperation and indeed the progress and direction of scientific research. Commercialisation, as it were, leads to the choice of direction. As Sir John Sulston said back in 2001, "the truth is that as a society we need to know a lot more than we choose to do."

The journal information provided by PLoS Clinical Trials shares much of this philosophy, explicitly stating that decisions to publish will not be determined by the perceived commercial import of the trial: "In order to maximize the number of trials whose results are available in the public domain, publication decisions will not be affected by the direction of results, size or perceived importance of the trial." This is the kind of "efficiency" that might be provided by ensuring broad and diverse publication driven, allowing excellence in research to drive publication potential rather than pre-emptive commercial indications. As Sir John Sulston said, "A consortium is not inefficient, it's the way things should be done. Everybody should pull their weight."

Tuesday, May 23, 2006

Citing Open Access Research


A University Health Network / University of Toronto Study states that open access articles have a distinct citation advantage over those published in subscription journals. In the report, "Citation Advantage of Open Access Articles," Gunther Eysenbach, Senior Scientist of the Centre for Global eHealth Innovation (a joint endeavour of the University Health Network and University of Toronto), states that open access achieves greater exchange of scholarly work, particularly in developing countries where open access publishing is the primary means by which researchers keep pace with research throughout the world.

Wednesday, March 22, 2006

The Politics and Ideology of Intellectual Property - A New Political Order





I've just returned from a 2 day meeting, organised by the Trans Atlantic Consumer Dialogue (TACD) (a coalition of 65 EU and US consumer organisations), staged in Brussels. The meeting was a very full and provocative event and a valuable demonstration of the motivation and engagement of civil society on intellectual property issues and development. Indeed, it demonstrated the ever increasing importance of civil society in international norm setting, and the undeniable importance of "consumers" (indeed, producers in their own right) as stakeholders in international intellectual property law debate.

Significantly, the 2 days were a rich and diverse mix of perspectives, interests, and backgrounds, and included papers from Bruce Lehman (pictured at left), Senior Counsel with Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld, and Chairman of the International Intellectual Property Institute IIIPI), a non-profit think tank and development organization located in Washington, D.C. From August 1993 through December 1998, Lehman served as Assistant Secretary of Commerce and Commissioner of the USPTO. As the Clinton Administration's primary representative for intellectual property rights protection, Lehman was involved in the negotiations leading to the TRIPS Agreement and the 1996 WIPO Copyright Treaties. Lehman made possibly one of the most highly blogged statements of recent days, saying "the TRIPS Agreement has been a huge failure for the United States," because in doing so the US agreed to provide market access to other countries with a comparative advantage on wages and the result has been that products are no longer manufactured in the US. Lehman maintained that it would have been preferable to have introduced labour and environmental standards into the agreement. "If anyone thinks this was a huge success for the United States they are 100% wrong."

In the final panel, Ed Mierzwinski (pictured at right), of Public Interest Research Groups PIRG, said that "the first message is that the old political model of the IP political economy is over" as is the model of creative process: "We have to protect the internet because it is the best opportunity we have to democratise information, protect diversity of culture, and ensure balance that's fair to all peoples of the world." Peter Drahos paraphrased John Stuart Mill, saying it was time "to allow for experiments in property." This, he said, was the key to recognising diversity rather than assuming that harmonisation is the only way to economic growth.

This was yet another brilliant event organised by TACD, in the tradition of the historic Future of WIPO Conference in Geneva in 2004. The indefatigable Jamie Love, Manon Ress, Ed Mierzwinski, Jill Johnstone, Ben Wallis, and a host of others should be congratulated for making these opportunities practical realities. As should every delegate in what was not only an invaluable but also a hugely motivating and engaging 2 days.

Make way for the new order.

Friday, March 10, 2006

Access to Knowledge Conference - Yale


Next month I will be speaking at the Yale Information Society Project (ISP) conference on Access to Knowledge, 21-23 April 2006. The event will cover a range of knowledge industries and issues of access, and I will be speaking in the panel on Agriculture and GM Crops.

The Access to Knowledge campaign is concerned with the "balance" or otherwise in intellectual property systems, strategic negotiations of intellectual property rights, and publishing and access initiatives that have emerged in recent years. A draft Treaty on Access to Knowledge has been produced by a growing coalition of civil society organisations in response to an increasing awareness and concern for cultural life and the necessary participation with and access to the knowledge tools necessary for social, cultural, and economic development.

A significant milestone in this debate was the Future of WIPO Meeting in Geneva, 2004, from which emerged the Declaration on the Future of WIPO with over 600 signatures. At this same meeting, representatives from Argentina and Brazil spoke on the proposal that was the basis for the adoption of the development agenda at the 31st Session of the WIPO General Assembly.

Tuesday, November 22, 2005

Intellectual Property - Territory for a New Empire?


In yesterday's Financial Times newspaper, a letter to the editor made some striking statements about the conflict between intellectual property rights and open access to knowledge in the context of growth in both developing and developed countries. The writer, Alfred B Engleberg (an intellectual property lawyer from Florida, USA), likens the globalisation of intellectual property rights (through increasing harmonisation of standards in line with the characteristics of industry in largely developed countries) to a new form of colonialism. Of interest to Patenting Lives were his comments regarding the need to access not only the benefits of research but also the tools for that research, access that may indeed be impeded through the application of patents. In other words, access not only to the benefit as the end-point of that research, but also to the incremental stages of innovation along the way. In light of the anticipated General Statement of the UN Committee on Economic Social and Cultural Rights (see early post), Engleberg's concerns regarding the prominence of industry in the negotiation of international trade and intellectual property developments are particularly relevant. And certainly, in view of the potential imbalances in the international system with respect to cultural, social, and economic priorities, the "cultural diversity" in the "creative economy" may never be "commercially viable."